Text: William Doyle Hull II, “Guide to the Canon: The New York Mirror,” A Canon of the Critical Works of Edgar Allan Poe (1941), pp. 16-23


∞∞∞∞∞∞∞


[page 16:]

THE NEW YORK EVENING MIRROR

October, 1844, through February, 1844.

     
OCTOBER 7, 1844.
   

THE AMBER-WITCH. W. [[EM, p. 3, col. 1]] [[discussion]]


     
OCTOBER 8, 1844.
   

* MISS BARRETT (no heading). W. [[EM, p. 1, cols. 1-2]] [[discussion]]


     
OCTOBER 9, 1844.
   

* DR. LARDNER’S LECTURE. W. [[EM, p. 3, cols. 1-2]] [[discussion]]


     
OCTOBER 26, 1844.
(?) 1.  

CHRUVELHIER’S ANATOMY [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

   

EMBURY’S AMERICAN WILD FLOWERS. W (?). [[EM, p. 3, cols. 1-2]] [[discussion]]


     
OCTOBER 29, 1844.
   

TRAVELS IN THE EAST. EOTHEN. W. [[EM, p. 1, col. 6 - p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]


     
OCTOBER 30, 1844.
? 2.  

SEWARD’S ELEMENTS OF EMPIRE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 7, 1844.
   

HOWITT’S MY UNCLE. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

   

[[HOW THE ENGLISH LIVE. MISS BUNBURY’S RIDES IN THE PYRENEES. W(?) EM, p. 2, col. 4 discussion — Hull lists this item only among the Weekly Mirror entries, although in the Evening Mirror, it immediately follows the review of Howitt's MY UNCLE.]]


     
NOVEMBER 11, 1844.
(?) 3.  

McCULLOCH’S GAZETEER. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

? 4.  

FROST’S BOOK OF THE ARMY. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

? 5.  

VALENTINE’S MANUAL. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 12, 1844.
   

* SKETCH OF THOMAS HOOD. W. [[EM, p. 1, col. 6]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 13, 1844.
   

* FREEMAN HUNT. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 14, 1844.
   

A NOBLEMAN’S SKETCHES. W ? [[EM, p. 2, cols. 4-5, etc.]] [[discussion]]

   

SMITH’S WEEKLY VOLUME. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 16, 1844.
   

A HUMBUG FAME. THOMAS CARLYLE. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2-3]] [[discussion]]

? 6.  

BOYD’S RHETORIC. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

7.  

SETTLERS IN CANADA. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

8.  

SIMMS’ FRANCIS MARION. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

   

* MacKELLAR’S DROPPINGS. H ?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

   

SPARK’S AMERICAN BIOGRAPHY. H ?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

   

GROWTH OF WESTERN LITERATURE. H ?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 18, 1844.
   

THE FAMILY CIRCLE. W ?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

MRS. CHILD’S FLOWERS. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

* AMELIA. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 19, 1844.
9.  

THOMAS’ THE BEECHEN TREE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 21, 1844.
   

MRS. GILMAN’S ORACLES. W. [[EM, p. 1, col. 6 - p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]] [page 17:]


     
NOVEMBER 22, 1844.
(?) 10.  

NEW YORK JOURNAL OF MEDICINE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 23, 1844.
   

NEW TRIAL OF CULPRIT POETS. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

11.  

DOWNING’S LANDSCAPE GARDENING, and COTTAGE RESIDENCES. [[EM, p. 2, col. 6]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 26, 1844.
   

MAGAZINES. W(?). [[EM, p. 3, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 27, 1844.
   

GRISWOLD’S POETS AND POETRY OF ENGLAND. W(?). [[EM, p. 3, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

   

ANTHON’S HOMER. W(?). [[EM, p. 3, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

   

GODEY’S LADY’S BOOK. W(?). [[EM, p. 3, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

   

PHYSIOLOGY OF THE MEDICAL STUDENT. W(?). [[EM, p. 3, col. 5]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 2, 1844.
   

HUNT’S MERCHANT’S MAGAZINE. W(?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 5, 1844.
12.  

GRIMES’ ETHEROLOGY. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 6, 1844.
   

THE AMERICAN REVIEW. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 7, 1844.
   

* MISS BARRETT. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 10, 1844. [[Hull has no entry for this date — JAS]]
   

[[THIRWALL's GREECE EM, p. 2, col. 4. Hull does not discuss this item, but seems to confuse the Weekly Mirror reprint with the announcement of January 17, 1845. Instead, this is a fuller notice. Since Hull does not appear to have discussed this item, his position on it is not clear — JAS]]


DECEMBER 12, 1844.
   

* MAGNIFICENT HOLIDAY PRESENT. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 6]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 13, 1844.
? 13.  

ARTHUR’S LADY’S MAGAZINE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

[[13a.  

COBB’S NORTH AMERICAN READER EM, p. 2, col. 6 discussion (Hull mistakenly gives this item only as appearing in the Weekly Mirror]]


     
DECEMBER 20, 1844.
14.  

ILLUSTRATED ASTRONOMY. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 21, 1844.
   

WHITNEY’S EVENING HOURS. H (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 23, 1844.
? 15.  

THE BOOK OF COMMON PRAYER. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

   

HOYT’S CHAUNT OF LIFE. H (?). [[EM, p. 4, col. 1]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 24, 1844.
   

MRS. CHILD’S FLOWERS. W(?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

McILVAINE’S EVIDENCES. W. (?) [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

(?) 16.  

LOVEL’S YOUNG SPEAKER. [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

? 17.  

SHAKSPEARE IN NEW DRESS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

   

LONDON ANNUALS. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

   

MRS. McDONALD’S POEMS. H?. [[EM, p. 4, col. 1]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 26, 1844.
   

BARTLETT’S JERUSALEM. W?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 28, 1844.
   

CHEEVER’S PILGRIM’S PROGRESS. W(?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

THE ROSE. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]] [page 18:]


     
DECEMBER 30, 1844.
? 18.  

GOLDSMITH’S GEMS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

HOLIDAY GIFTS. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

THE KEEPSAKE. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 4, 1845.
   

WHAT IS POETRY. W. [[EM, p. 1, col. 6, etc.]] [[discussion]] [[This series of extracts is continued in the issue for January 7, 1845. In WM it appears as one long piece.]]


     
JANUARY 6, 1845.
   

* HOSMER’S YONNONDIO. (Signed. By a Lady of Western New York). [[EM, p. 1, col. 6]] [[discussion (not really any discussion)]]


     
JANUARY 9, 1845.
* 19.  

DOES THE DRAMA OF THE DAY DESERVE SUPPORT. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 10, 1845.
20.  

MAGAZINIANA. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

MRS. SIGOURNEY’S SCENES. W?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

COMMON AND SCRIPTURAL PROVERBS. W?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

A TWELFTH-DAY PRESENT. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

HUNT’S MERCHANT’S MAGAZINE. W (?). [[EM, p. 4, col. 1]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 11, 1845.
   

LEIGH HUNT’S IMAGINATION AND FANCY. (B). H?. [[EM, p. 1, col. 6, etc.]] [[discussion]]

* 21.  

ALPHADELPHIA TOXIN [[TOCSIN]]. (B). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

* 22.  

LOWELL’S CONVERSATIONS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

LETTERS FROM A LANDSCAPE PAINTER. W?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 13, 1845.
* 23.  

LONGFELLOW’S WAIF. (C, B). [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2-3]] [[discussion]]

   

CRANCH’S POEMS. H?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 6]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 14, 1845.
? 24.  

NAPOLEON’S MAXIMS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

* 25.  

LONGFELLOW’S WAIF. (C, B). [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

26.  

THE SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

? 27.  

GOLDSMITH’S GEMS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

? 28.  

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF FINE ARTS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 15, 1845.
(?) 29.  

CHALMER’S INTRODUCTION. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 16, 1845.
(?) 30.  

IRISH IMIGRANTS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

(?) 31.  

RESTORATION OF THE JEWS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

COLUMBIAN MAGAZINE. W?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 17, 1845.
* 32.  

NATURE AND ART. (C, B). [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

? 33.  

THIRWALL’S GREECE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

(?) 34.  

WESTMINSTER REVIEW. [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

(?) 35.  

BROADWAY JOURNAL. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

(?) 36.  

SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

* 37.  

CRITICISM. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

(?) 38.  

THE BRANDED HAND. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

(?) 39.  

THE NATIONAL PROTESTANT. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

? 40.  

PETER PARLEY’S GEOGRAPHY. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 18, 1845.
(?) 41.  

GODEY’S LADY’S BOOK. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]] [page 19:]


     
JANUARY 20, 1845.
42.  

DR. DRAPER. [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

* 43.  

POST-NOTES BY THE CRITIC. (B). [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2-3]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 21, 1845.
   

COBB’S READER„ W?. (?) [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]

(?) 44.  

HOOD’S WHIMSICALITIES. [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 22, 1845.
   

COX’S HALLOWEEN. H (?). [[EM, p. 1, col. 6]] [[discussion]]

* 45.  

AMERICAN DIFFUSENESS — OBJECTIONABLE CONCISION. (C, B). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 23, 1845.
(?) 46.  

A NEW WORK BY MATHEWS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

? 47.  

MEDICAL LEXICON. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 25, 1845.
? 48.  

LITTELL’S LIVING AGE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 27, 1845.
49.  

NIEBUBR’S HISTORY OF ROME. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 1-2]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 28, 1845.
   

A LATIN PROSODY. H (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 6]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 29, 1845.
   

ILLUSTRATED GENEALOGY. W?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

(?) 50.  

WESTMINSTER REVIEW. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2]] [[discussion]]

? 51.  

PARRINGTON’S IRISH NATION. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2]] [[discussion]]

? 52.  

DURIVAGE’S MIKE MARTIN. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

NEW WORLD. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 31, 1845.
   

* AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE AND ARTS. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 3, 1845.
* 53.  

INCREASE OF POETICAL HERESY — DIDACTICISM. (C, B). [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

54.  

SOUTHERN QUARTERLY REVIEW. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

55.  

MAUNDER’S TREASURY. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

56.  

KINNE’S COMPENDIUM. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

57.  

THE ORION. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

? 58.  

LITTELL’S LIVING AGE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

? 59.  

MARSH’S ADDRESS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

60.  

PRESCOTT’S FERDINAND AND ISABELLA. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

61.  

BROADWAY JOURNAL. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2-3]] [[discussion]]

? 62.  

RESEARCHES. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

? 63.  

MARTIN’S BIBLE. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 5, 1845.
   

* LONGFELLOW’S WAIF. W. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2-3]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 6, 1845.
64.  

LITERARY INTELLIGENCE. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 3-4]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 7, 1845.
* 65.  

THE AMERICAN REVIEW. [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

   

* HUNT’S MERCHANT’S MAGAZINE. W. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 1-2]] [[discussion]]

? 66.  

SCOTT’S REPRINT OF BLACKWOOD. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

67.  

MRS. ELIZABETH OAKES SMITH. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

* A NEW ERA IN THE ENGLISH DRAMA. W. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2-3]] [[discussion]] [page 20:]


     
FEBRUARY 12, 1845.
   

* MR. GILLESPIE’S BOOK. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

* 68.  

MAGAZINE LITERATURE. (B). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 13, 1845.
? 69.  

THE LONDON LANCET. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 14, 1845.
   

GRAHAM FOR MARCH. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

* PARAGRAPH ON THE POE-LONGFELLOW WAR (no heading) W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 15, 1845.
* 70.  

IMITATION — PLAGIARISM. (C, B). [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

* 71.  

THE HON. ROBERT T. CONRAD. (?) [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

(?) 72.  

MR. SAUNDERS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

? 73.  

GRISCOM’S CONDITIONS. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 17, 1845.
* 74.  

PLAGIARISM.[[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

   

* MEMORIAL OF FITCH. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

THIERS’ NAPOLEON. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

HOWITT’S MY OWN STORY. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 18, 1845.
   

JARVIS’ INTRODUCTION. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 1]] [[discussion]]

(?) 75.  

STANLEY’S ARNOLD.[[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

FAUST. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 19, 1845.
   

COUNTESS BLESSINGTON’S NEW BOOK. W. [[EM, p. 2, cols. 2-4]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 20, 1845.
   

EDINBURGH REVIEW W?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 21, 1845.
   

COLUMBIAN MAGAZINE. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]

   

FEMALE STOCKBROKERS. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 4]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 22, 1845.
   

TWO BOOKS ON WOMEN. H ?. [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

LONDON QUARTERLY. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 3]] [[discussion]]

   

TAYLOR’S MANUAL. W (?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 5]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 24, 1845.
   

SHEW’S HYDROPATHY. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]

   

ANASTASIS. W. [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 27, 1845.
   

LIBRARY OF AMERICAN BIOGRAPHY. W(?). [[EM, p. 2, col. 2]] [[discussion]]


[page 21:]

THE NEW YORK WEEKLY MIRROR (1)

October, 1844, through February, 1845.

     
OCTOBER 12, 1844.
   

(* DR. LARDNER’S LECTURE. p. 3. [[WM, p. 3]] W.) [[EM discussion]]

   

(AMBER-WITCH. p. 4. [[WM, p. 4]] W(?).). [[EM discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 2, 1844.
   

(TRAVELS IN THE EAST EOTHEN. p. 52. [[WM, p. 52]] W.). [[EM discussion]]

   

GRAHAM’S MAGAZINE. p. 63. W(?). [[WM, p. 63]] [[discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 17, 1844.
   

HOW THE ENGLISH LIVE. MISS BUNBURY’S RIDES IN THE PYRENEES. p. 84. [[WM, p. 84]] W(?) [[discussion]]

   

(* SKETCH OF HOOD. p. 94. [[WM, p. 94]] W.) [[EM discussion]]

( ? 4.  

FROST’S BOOK OF THE ARMY. p. 96. [[WM, p. 96]] ) [[EM discussion]]

( (?) 3.  

McCULLOCH’S GAZETEER. p. 96. [[WM, p. 96]] ) [[EM discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 23, 1844.
   

[[(FREEMAN HUNT. p. 105. W. [[WM, p. 105]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(A NOBLEMAN’S SKETCHES. p. 110. W ?. ) [[WM, pp. 110-111]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(FAMILY CIRCLE. p. 111. W?.) [[WM, p. 111]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(HOWITT’S [[CHILD’S]] FLOWERS FOR CHILDREN. p. 111. W(?). ) [[WM, p. 111]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* AMELIA. p. 111. W. ) [[WM, pp. 111]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* MacKELLAR’S DROPPINGS. p. 111. H?. ) [[WM, p. 111]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( GROWTH OF WESTERN LITERATURE. p. 111. H?. ) [[WM, p. 111]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( A HUMBUG FAME. THOMAS CARLYLE. p. 112. W(?). ) [[WM, p. 112]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( SPARK’S AMERICAN BIOGRAPHY. p. 112. H?. ) [[WM, p. 112]] [[EM discussion]]

( ? 6.  

BOYD’S RHETORIC. p. 112. ) [[WM, p. 112]] [[EM discussion]]

( 7.  

MARRYATT’S SETTLERS IN CANADA. p. 112. ) [[WM, p. 112]] [[EM discussion]]

( 8.  

SIMMS’ FRANCIS MARION. p. 112. ) [[WM, p. 112]] [[EM discussion]]


     
NOVEMBER 30, 1844.
   

( MRS. GILMAN’S ORACLES. p. 120. W. ) [[WM, pp. 120-121]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( NEW TRIAL OF CULPRIT POETS, p. 121. W. ) [[WM, p. 121]] [[EM discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 7, 1844.
   

PERSONAL NOTICES OF ELIZABETH BARRETT. p. 135. (C, B). W. [[WM, p. 135]] [[discussion]]

   

( GRISWOLD’S POETS AND POETRY OF ENGLAND. p. 144. W (?). ) [[WM, p. 144]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( ANTHON’S HOMER, p. 144. W (?). ) [[WM, p. 144]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( GODEY’S LADY’S BOOK. p. 144. W (?). ) [[WM, p. 144]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( PHYSIOLOGY OF THE MEDICAL STUDENT. p. 144. W (?). ) [[WM, p. 144]] [[EM discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 14, 1844.
( ? 33.  

THIRWALL’S GREECE. p. 146. ) [[WM, p. 146]] [[This entry, reprinted from the EM of December 10, 1844, is not the same as the announcement of January 17, 1845. Hull seems to have confused these items. — JAS.]]

   

REVUE FRANCAISE. p. 146. W (?). [[WM, p. 144]] [[discussion]]

( 12.  

GRIMES’ ETHEROLOGY. p. 146. ) [[WM, p. 146]] [[EM discussion]]


     
DECEMBER 21, 1844.
   

WHITE’S GOODNESS. p. 164. W. [[WM, p. 164]] [[discussion]]

1.  

COBB’S READER. p. 164. [[WM, p. 164]] [[discussion]]

   

ZSCHOKKE’S HOURS OF MEDITATION. p. 164. W (?). [[WM, p. 164]] [[discussion]] [page 22:]


     
DECEMBER 28, 1844.
   

(McILVAINE’S EVIDENCES. p. 178. W. ) [[WM, p. 178]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(MRS. CHILD’S FLOWERS FOR CHILDREN. p. 178. W (?). ) [[WM, p. 178]] [[EM discussion]]

( 14.  

ILLUSTRATED ASTRONOMY. p. 180. ) [[WM, p. 180]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(BARTLETT’S JERUSALEM. p. 182. W ?. ) [[WM, p. 182]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(LONDON ANNUALS. p. 184. W (?). ) [[WM, p. 184]] [[EM discussion]]


     
JANUARY 4, 1845.
( ? 18.  

GOLDSMITH’S GEMS. p. 200.) [[WM, p. 200]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(PILGRIM’S PROGRESS. p. 203. W(?).) [[WM, p. 203]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(THE KEEPSAKE. p. 203. W.) [[WM, p. 203]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(THE ROSE. p. 203. W.) [[WM, p. 203]] [[EM discussion]]


     
JANUARY 11, 1845.
   

[[(* HOSMER’S YONNONDIO. p. 212 (Signed. By a Lady of Western New York). [[WM, p. 212]] EM discussion (not really any discussion)]]

   

(WHAT IS POETRY. pp.216-217. W. [[WM, pp. 216-17]] ) [[EM discussion]]

   

(HUNT’S MERCHANT’S MAGAZINE. p. 219. W (?). ) [[WM, p. 219]] [[discussion]]


     
JANUARY 18, 1845.
( 20.  

MAGAZINIANA. p. 227.) [[WM, p. 227]] [[EM discussion]]

(* 21.  

ALPHADELPHIA TOXIN [[TOCSIN]]. (C, B). p. 227.) [[WM, p. 227]] [[EM discussion]]

(* 22.  

LOWELL’S CONVERSATIONS. (C, B, R, P). p. 227 [[p. 239]]. ) [[WM, p. 239]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(LETTERS FROM A LANDSCAPE PAINTER. p. 227. W?.) [[WM, p. 227]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(HUNT’S IMAGINATION AND FANCY. (B, R, P). pp. 228-229. H?.) [[WM, pp. 228-29]] [[EM discussion]]

(* 19.  

DOES THE DRAMA OF THE DAY DESERVE SUPPORT. (C, B, R, P). p. 229.) [[WM, p. 229]] [[EM discussion]]

   

HUNT’S MERCHANT’S MAGAZINE. p. 230. W(?). [[WM, p. 230]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(MRS. SIGOURNEY’S SCENES. p. 238. W?.) [[WM, p. 238]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(COMMON AND SCRIPTURAL PROVERBS. p. 238. W?.) [[WM, p. 238]] [[EM discussion]]


     
JANUARY 25, 1845.
(* 32.  

NATURE AND ART. (C, B). p. 249. ) [[WM, p. 249]] [[EM discussion]]

(* 23, 25.  

LONGFELLOW’S WAIF. (C, B, R, P). pp. 250-51. ) [[WM, pp. 250-251]] [[EM discussion and EM second part]]

(* 43.  

POST-NOTES BY THE CRITIC. (C, B). p. 251. ) [[WM, p. 251]] [[EM discussion]]

   

( CRANCH’S POEMS. p. 256. H?. ) [[WM, p. 256]] [[EM discussion]]

(?) 2.  

BROOKS’ ADDRESS. p. 256. [[WM, p. 256]] [[discussion]]

( (?) 29.  

CHALMER’S INTRODUCTION. p. 256.) [[WM, p. 256]] [[EM discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 1, 1845.
( 42.  

DR. DRAPER. p. 268.) [[WM, p. 268]] [[EM discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 8, 1845.
( (?) 50.  

WESTMINSTER REVIEW. p. 278.) [[WM, p. 278]] [[EM discussion]]

( ? 51.  

BARRINGTON’S (sic) IRISH NATION. p. 279.) [[WM, p. 278]] [[EM discussion]]

(* 53.  

INCREASE OF POETICAL HERESY — DIDACTICISM. (C, B). p. 279.) [[WM, p. 279]] [[EM discussion]]

[[( ? 63.  

MARTIN’S BIBLE. p. 281. )]] [[WM, p. 281]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE AND ARTS. p. 286. W.) [[WM, p. 286]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* LONGFELLOW’S WAIF. p. 286. [[p. 287.]] W.) [[WM, p. 287]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(ILLUSTRATED GENEALOGY. p. 286. [[p. 288]] W?.) [[WM, p. 288]] [[EM discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 15, 1845.
(* 68.  

MAGAZINE LITERATURE. (C, B). p. 299.) [[WM, p. 299]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* NEW ERA IN ENGLISH DRAMA. p. 301. W.) [[WM, p. 301]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* MR. GILLESPIE’S NEW BOOK. p. 301. [[p. 303]] W.) [[WM, p. 303]] [[EM discussion]]

   

TRIBUNE FOR TUESDAY [[THURSDAY]]. p. 304. W (?). [[WM, p. 304]] [[discussion]]

(* 65.  

THE AMERICAN REVIEW. p. 304. ) [[WM, p. 304]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* HUNT’S MERCHANT’S MAGAZINE. p. 304. W. ) [[WM, p. 304]] [[EM discussion]]

( ? 66.  

SCOTT’S REPRINT OF BLACKWOOD. p. 304. ) [[WM, p. 304]] [[EM discussion]]

( 67.  

MRS. ELIZABETH OAKES SMITH. p. 304. ) [[WM, p. 304]] [[EM discussion]]

( 64.  

LITERARY INTELLIGENCE. (C?). p. 304. ) [[WM, p. 304]] [[EM discussion]]


     
FEBRUARY 22, 1845.
(* 70.  

IMITATION — PLAGIARISM. (C, B). p. 306. ) [[WM, p. 306]] [[EM discussion]]

( ? 73.  

GRISCOM’S CONDITIONS. p. 308. ) [[WM, p. 308]] [[EM discussion]]

(* 74.  

PLAGIARISM. (C, B). p. 310. ) [[WM, p. 310]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(JARVIS’ INTRODUCTION. p. 315. W(?). ) [[WM, p. 315]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(* MEMORIAL OF FITCH. p. 315. W(?). ) [[WM, p. 315]] [[EM discussion]]

( (?) 75.  

STANLEY’S ARNOLD. p. 315. ) [[WM, p. 315]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(THIERS’ NAPOLEON. p. 315. W(?). ) [[WM, p. 315]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(HOWITT’S MY OWN STORY. p. 315. W(?). ) [[WM, p. 315]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(FAUST. p. 315. W. ) [[WM, p. 315]] [[EM discussion]]

[[some additional reprints from the February Evening Mirror — JAS:]]

THE NEW YORK WEEKLY MIRROR

March, 1845.

     
March 1, 1844.
   

(SHEW’S HYDROPATHY. p. 327. W. [[WM, p. 327]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(ANASTASIS. p. 327. W. [[WM, p. 327]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(COUNTESS BLESSINGTON’S NEW BOOK. p. 328. W. [[WM, pp. 328-329]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(FEMALE STOCKBROKERS. p. 332 W. [[WM, p. 332]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(COLUMBIAN MAGAZINE. p. 332 W (?). [[WM, p. 332]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(EDINBURGH REVIEW p. 333. W?. [[WM, p. 333]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(TWO BOOKS ON WOMEN. p. 336. H ?. [[WM, p. 336]] [[EM discussion]]

   

(TAYLOR’S MANUAL. p. 336. W (?). [[WM, p. 336]] [[EM discussion]]



[[Footnotes]]

[The following footnote appears at the bottom of page 21:]

1.  The articles reprinted from the Evening Mirror are here in parentheses; those by Poe retain the numbering of the canon for the Evening Mirror.


∞∞∞∞∞∞∞

[S:0 - CCWEAP, 1941] - Edgar Allan Poe Society of Baltimore - Articles - A Canon of the Critical Works of EAP (W. D. Hull) (Guide to the Canon: NYM)